One of the easiest ways to clean up a dusty or cluttered home is to use a best vacuum cleaner. But, all the vacuum cleaners are not the same. Each has distinct features that help you make cleaning more effective. One such important element that distinguishes while choosing a vacuum cleaner is the beater bar.
Some vacuum comes with a beater bar while some do not. So, which one is best: the one with a beater bar or the one without it? Here is a detailed comparison between both types of vacuum cleaners so that you can get a clear picture of it and invest in the right model.
But before diving into the comparison elements, let us first understand what is a beater bar, its importance, and how it works?
What Is a Beater Bar in a Vacuum?
A beater bar, also known as a bristle bar or brush bar, is actually a smoothly contoured metal agitator bar that is fixed to the rotating brush rolls. As the beater bar rotates, it gently beats the fibers using bristle brushes, thus loosening the dirt and dust from surfaces (generally from rugs and carpets). It also allows the brushes to comb away the dirt into the suction port of the vacuum.
The beater bar in a vacuum was first introduced by Hoover in the early 1920s in order to agitate and lift dirt and debris from deep inside the carpets. But, in the latest vacuum cleaners, the design of the rotating brush rolls has changed. They come with more stiffer brushes along with varying bristle lengths for perfect cleaning.
How Does a Beater Bar Work?
The beater bar works by spinning at high speed, which gives a prominent vibration to the carpet. This vibration helps in loosening the deep soil, and dirt stuck deep inside the carpet. The loosen dirt and debris are then sucked up by the vacuum’s suction system and transferred to the dirt compartment. Finally, the brush bristles that are attached to the vacuum’s beater bar helps in brushing the carpet and cleaning the dirt from it more effectively.
Not just that, the beater bar in a vacuum also helps in the effective cleaning of pet hair, yarn, etc., from your fluffy carpets and rugs.
Beater Bar Vs. No Beater Bar Vacuum- Comparison Elements
For What Surface Are They Best For?
The beater bar vacuum cleaners are ideally best for thick and fluffy carpets (high pile carpets). They effectively clean dirt, pet hair, yarn, etc., from deep inside the carpet. But, the most important point to note here is that the vacuum cleaners with beater bars may cause damage to certain rugs and carpets, including low and medium-pile carpets. They are also not recommended for vacuuming hardwood floors since they may scratch or damage these surfaces.
On the other hand, if you want to clean shag rugs, hardwood, tile, laminated, or vinyl flooring, no beater bar vacuums are the best choice; instead, you can use a good suction type vacuum only.
Which is Best For Pet Hair?
If you have pets in your homes, the hair shed by them is very common all-around your home. The easiest way to remove pet hair from hardwood floors is to use a good suction-only vacuum. But what about the carpets where the pet hair and other kinds of dirt are deeply embedded into them?
Once again, the beater bar vacuum wins in this situation. They have the capability to deep clean your fluffy carpets making them hygienic and sparkling clean.
Check Here for the Best Vacuum Cleaners for Pet Hair
Overall Maintenance Cost
Regular vacuum maintenance is essential for its optimal performance and efficiency. In the vacuums with a beater bar, the brush roll spins at high RPM, making bristles worn out quickly. This decreases the efficiency of the vacuum. So, the brush roll must be changed to continue with effective cleaning.
Sometimes the beater bar drive belt also worn out, resulting in the noisy operation of the unit. To ensure noise-free operation of the vacuum, the drive belt also requires replacement.
In short, the more you use your vacuum, the more frequently you need to replace the beater bar or brush roller. This adds to the overall maintenance cost of the vacuum cleaner with a beater bar. Thankfully, with no beater bar vacuum, you can avoid this cost.
Do all Vacuums Have Beater Bar?
Some of these, as a plus point, comes with a beater bar on/off switch, so you can use them on all surface types. Turn the brush roll OFF for vacuuming delicate rugs & carpets, and hardwood floors. And for vacuuming thick carpets, turn on the brush roll for effective cleaning of it.
Some also come with a removable beater bar, so that you can easily clean and maintain it to retain its efficiency.
Where to Use Beater Bar Vacuum?
Beater bar vacuums are best to clean thick and fluffy carpets, also known as high-pile carpets, as they can deeply clean the dirt, debris, and pet hair deeply embedded into them.
Where to Use No Beater Bar Vacuum?
No beater bar vacuums are best to use for vacuuming delicate and fragile rugs and carpets and hardwood floorings, including laminated, wooden, tile, vinyl, etc. If you use beater bar vacuums on these surfaces, chances of scratches and damages are high.
Pros and Cons of Vacuums with Beater Bar
- Best suited for homes with thick carpets.
- The carpet fibers can trap dirt and pet hair easily, and over time, it gets deeply embedded into the surface. To loosen the dirt, debris, and pet hair, a good vacuum with a beater bar is the best solution.
- Easy and efficient.
- Can damage the shag and fragile carpets. It also creates scratches on hardwood floorings.
- Requires a lot of maintenance and frequent replacement too.
Pros and Cons of Vacuums Without Beater Bar
- Best to use on hardwood floorings, stairs, and upholsteries.
- Can clean pet hair and other debris.
- No need for beater bar replacement that saves the additional cost.
- Can not clean deeply embedded dirt and dust from the thick carpets.
So which type of vacuum is best: With a beater bar or Without a Beater Bar?
Well, both have their pros and cons, and the decision really comes down to the type of flooring you have. If you have a lot of carpets and pets, buying a vacuum with a beater bar is the best choice. If you have floorings like vinyl, tile, or laminated, then no beater bar vacuum is the best to go with without causing damage to these surfaces. And if you have a mixture of flooring, consider choosing the one with a brush roll on/off switch so you can easily adjust it according to the type of surface you want to clean.